Finnigan Doodles: Which Bear Should I Choose?

I found these doodles in one of my scanners yesterday. They're a few months old, and rougher version of these characters, but I like them. Esau the Donkey is always fun to draw.

Here I was experimenting with the look of some of my bears. I threw Finnigan and Orange in just to provide some interaction. I'm really torn on the look I want for Carl the Bear (The second and third bear designs) Any feedback would be helpful.

Which Carl is more appealing?: The squat bear with shorts on the left, or the taller, more inquisitive version on the right?